My ideas for American Idol guest judges 2011?
July 7th, 2010 . by adminQuestion by Mike D: My ideas for American Idol guest judges 2011?
I still plan on watching American Idol season 10, even though it won’t be the same without Simon and Paula. But I think it would be cool if they had guest judges again like last year, so I decided just for fun to make a list of guest judges I think would be great for Season 10.
Please comment on my idea and give your opinions. I know some people won’t be on there that you would like but all the people I chose I think would be great judges as they all do have experience in the music industry, and they are all great artists in their own rights.
1. Lady GaGa
2. Shakira
3. Madonna
4. Eminem
5. Andy Slater (President and CEO of Capitol Records)
6. Elton John
7. Bob Marley
8. Miley Cyrus (I know people aren’t going to agree with this one but you have to admit she has gone far in the music industry for a 17 year old)
9. Dolly Parton
10. Beyonce
Also, yes I know Justin Bieber isn’t on there (the shock! the horror!) but thats simply because I don’t think he has had enough experience in the music industry yet. Also one teen is enough and Miley Cyrus has had more experience in recording, live performing etc than him. So I chose her.
Thanks for any answers 
Best answer:
Answer by ♥Rachel♥
No not Lady gaga or Eminiem.
Give your answer to this question below!
I think Elton would be pretty good, as I think he would be honest whilst trying to help.
Erm….Bob Marley died a few decades ago so….that kinda rules him out…
Miley has done alot in the business, you’re right. But her stint as a mentor showed that she’s not someone who can be honest and risk putting someone down when it calls for it.
I actually think Katy Perry could do a great job; I thought she did well when she was a guest judge, but if not her, I think Harry Connick Jnr would be fantastic. The guy is amazingly talented and did a great job as a mentor.